Demographic Decline and Entitlements reform

The transfer of wealth from working-aged Canadians to retirees is continuing to rise.

“I would humbly recommend we stop doing that,” says economist and Macdonald-Laurier Institute senior fellow Trevor Tombe.

It’s an issue many Western democracies are grappling with as birthrates decline and the population pyramids that many social programs were based upon become inverted.

As our population ages, ever more public resources will flow from working-age Canadians to seniors. The portion of the population that is not in the workforce will rise, and the already significant cost burden on the younger generation suffering under a glut of regulatory morass keeping housing costs high and income growth tepid.

Trevor and I discuss the practical and political consequences of this generational tension and the forthcoming research on the fiscal consequences of population aging, and the case for serious entitlement reform.

We also explore what I take to be a more fundamental question. Much of neoclassical economics seems to assume that technology and the attendant productivity gains it entails can continually offset declining populations.

Much of our economic dynamism in the past two centuries has depended on growing populations and declining mortality. With it has come expanding markets through higher consumer demand, the division of labour that allows for specialization and therefore greater productivity, and all the innovation that flows from the two in concert. This feedback loop depends on a growing population.

It’s worth asking what happens when the spiral stops. The world population is set to peak in the coming decades, then may rapidly decline if current coupling and fertility projections are to hold.

There are of course, numerous costs that don’t show up on a government’s balance sheet, including fewer marriages and families, greater loneliness and isolation, and potentially weaker social trust and community life.

Technology may help us care for an aging population in the short-term. But I have my doubts that it can replace the economic and social goods that come from human relationships and flourishing families. In fact, it may radically undermine them. Just like mass immigration gives us an ongoing sugar high, letting us neglect per capital GDP and productivity and along with it fertility, the continued reliance on technology is, I think, the same kind of myopic thinking that will result in a big sugar crash in a few decades time. Just as we are now seeing the issues with excessive immigration, we’ll start seeing the impact of demographic decline soon enough.

A fascinating conversation about the future of Canada’s economy, our social programs, and the generational bargain.

Podcast formats available here

Leave a Reply